Jennifer Louise Robinson
(24-33060)
United States Bankruptcy Court, S.D. Texas
JUL 1, 2024 | REPUBLISHED BY LIT: AUG 22, 2024
LIT : Summary of Underwater Loan and Repayment Plan
The debtor holds an underwater mortgage with a total secured debt of $724,119.69, while the property is valued at $548,600. As a result, the excess debt can be treated as an unsecured claim and is eligible for lien stripping in her Chapter 13 bankruptcy plan.
The specifics of the approved plan can be reviewed in the tab below (Amended plan, Doc. 48).
The repayment plan outlines a commitment period of 60 months, starting with monthly payments of $4,000 for the first year, which aligns with her disposable income of approximately $4,004.03.
This amount is sustainable based on her current financial situation. Starting in the second year, payments increase to $9,985 per month, reflecting anticipated future income increases.
While the initial payments are manageable, the success of the plan relies on the debtor’s ability to meet these higher payments in later months.
If the debtor fails to complete the plan, the stripped lien could revert to a valid secured claim, allowing the lender to pursue foreclosure or collection actions.
Overall, the plan seeks to balance current income with future financial expectations, aiming for successful debt resolution while addressing the underwater loan situation.
Based on the financial statements presented in the amended plan, LIT argues that the plan lacks realism and serves primarily as a temporary measure to divert scrutiny from attorney Clay Vilt, rather than genuinely assisting the debtor. It is evident that the approved plan hinges on the withdrawal of objections from Deutsche Bank and its counsel, as well as a judge willing to issue an order that he recognizes is not practical.
BANKRUPTCY JUDGE NORMAN’S ORDER
ORDER CONFIRMING CHAPTER 13 PLAN AND VALUING COLLATERAL PURSUANT TO 11 U.S.C. § 506
1. The Court has considered confirmation of the Debtor(s)’ chapter 13 plan that was proposed on 9/17/24.
2. All objections to the plan have been withdrawn or overruled.
3. The Court has determined that the plan meets all of the requirements of §1325 of the Bankruptcy Code.
4. Notwithstanding any estimate of the amount of a general or priority unsecured claim contained in the plan or in an order of the Court, the actual amount payable on priority claims will be the Allowed Amount of the priority claim and the actual proration for distribution on general unsecured claims will be based on actual Allowed Amounts of general unsecured claims.
5. The value of the collateral for secured claims is in the amount set forth in the plan.
6. The plan is confirmed.
Signed and Entered on Docket: 10/4/24.
Amended Chapter 13 Plan, Amended Chapter 13 Plan Summary Filed by Jennifer Louise Robinson.
(Southward, Eric) (Entered: 09/17/2024)
Withdraw Document (Filed By Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as Trustee, in trust for registered Holders of Long Beach Mortgage Loan Trust 2006- 3, Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-3 ).
(Related document(s):33 Objection to Confirmation of the Plan) (Dunn, George) (Entered: 10/02/2024)
Order/Courtroom Minutes.
Reset dismissal.
Before Judge Norman, Jeffrey P. Related to document 39.
Reset to 10/10/2024 at 09:30AM.
(srh4) (Entered: 09/12/2024)
DUPFILER |
Southern District of Texas (Houston)
Bankruptcy Petition #: 24-33060
Assigned to: Bankruptcy Judge Jeffrey P Norman Chapter 13 Voluntary Asset
|
|
Debtor Jennifer Louise Robinson 3111 Longhorn Circle Manvel, TX 77578 BRAZORIA-TX SSN / ITIN: xxx-xx-5924 |
represented by | Eric Southward Busby & Associates 715 E Whitney St Houston, TX 77022 713-974-8099 Fax : 713-974-1181 Email: esouthward@busby-lee.com |
Trustee Tiffany D Castro 1220 Augusta Drive Ste 500 Houston, TX 77057 713-722-1200 |
||
U.S. Trustee US Trustee Office of the US Trustee 515 Rusk Ave Ste 3516 Houston, TX 77002 713-718-4650 |
Filing Date | # | Docket Text | |
---|---|---|---|
09/17/2024 | 48 | Amended Chapter 13 Plan, Amended Chapter 13 Plan Summary Filed by Jennifer Louise Robinson. (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 09/17/2024) | |
09/17/2024 | 49 | Amended Schedule G Individual- Executory Contracts and Unexpired Leases , Amended Schedule I: Individual- Your Income , Amended Schedule J Individual- Your Expenses (Filed By Jennifer Louise Robinson ). (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 09/17/2024) | |
09/18/2024 | 50 | Amended Schedule I: Individual- Your Income , Amended Schedule J Individual- Your Expenses , Declaration About Individual Debtor’s Schedules (Filed By Jennifer Louise Robinson ). (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 09/18/2024) | |
09/18/2024 | 51 | Withdraw Document (Filed By Brazoria County, et al And Brazoria County Municipal Utility District #25 ).(Related document(s):42 Objection to Confirmation of the Plan) (Randermann, Angela) (Entered: 09/18/2024) | |
09/30/2024 | 52 | Notice on Financial Management Course Requirement. (Entered: 09/30/2024) | |
10/02/2024 | 53 | Withdraw Document (Filed By Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as Trustee, in trust for registered Holders of Long Beach Mortgage Loan Trust 2006- 3, Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-3 ).(Related document(s):33 Objection to Confirmation of the Plan) (Dunn, George) (Entered: 10/02/2024) | |
10/02/2024 | 54 | BNC Certificate of Mailing. (Related document(s):52 Notice on Financial Management Course Requirement) No. of Notices: 1. Notice Date 10/02/2024. (Admin.) (Entered: 10/02/2024) | |
10/03/2024 | 55 | Amended Schedule A/B: Property for Individual , Amended Schedule C , Declaration About Individual Debtor’s Schedules (Filed By Jennifer Louise Robinson ). (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 10/03/2024) | |
10/04/2024 | 56 | Withdrawal of Motion to Dismiss (Related document(s):39 Chapter 13 Trustee’s Motion to Dismiss Case) (Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 10/04/2024) | |
10/04/2024 | 57 | Chapter 13 Trustee’s Amended Recommendation Concerning Confirmation. The Trustee now recommends confirmation of the plan filed on 9/17/2024, document number 48 (Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 10/04/2024) | |
10/04/2024 | 58 | Order Confirming Plan and Valuing Collateral Pursuant to 11 USC 506. (Related document(s):48 Amended Chapter 13 Plan, Amended Chapter 13 Plan Summary) Chapter 13 Plan filed 9/17/2024. (trc4) (Entered: 10/04/2024) | |
10/06/2024 | 59 | BNC Certificate of Mailing. (Related document(s):58 Courtroom Minutes/Order – C2 MI DJ ER JN CL) No. of Notices: 4. Notice Date 10/06/2024. (Admin.) (Entered: 10/06/2024) |
PACER Service Center | |||
---|---|---|---|
Transaction Receipt | |||
10/25/2024 17:18:44 |
DUPFILER |
Southern District of Texas (Houston)
Bankruptcy Petition #: 24-33060
Assigned to: Bankruptcy Judge Jeffrey P Norman Chapter 13 Voluntary Asset
|
|
Debtor Jennifer Louise Robinson 3111 Longhorn Circle Manvel, TX 77578 BRAZORIA-TX SSN / ITIN: xxx-xx-5924 |
represented by | Eric Southward Busby & Associates 715 E Whitney St Houston, TX 77022 713-974-8099 Fax : 713-974-1181 Email: esouthward@busby-lee.com |
Trustee Tiffany D Castro Office of Chapter 13 Trustee 9821 Katy Freeway Ste 590 Houston, TX 77024 713-722-1200 |
||
U.S. Trustee US Trustee Office of the US Trustee 515 Rusk Ave Ste 3516 Houston, TX 77002 713-718-4650 |
Filing Date | # | Docket Text | |
---|---|---|---|
09/11/2024 | 42 (4 pgs) |
Objection to Confirmation of Plan Filed by Brazoria County, et al And Brazoria County Municipal Utility District #25. (Related document(s):19 Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary) (Randermann, Angela) (Entered: 09/11/2024) | |
09/12/2024 | 43 (3 pgs) |
Response (related document(s):39 Chapter 13 Trustee’s Motion to Dismiss Case). Filed by Jennifer Louise Robinson (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 09/12/2024) | |
09/12/2024 | 44 (1 pg) |
Order/Courtroom Minutes. Reset confirmation. Before Judge Norman, Jeffrey P. Related to document 30. Reset to 10/10/2024 at 09:30AM. (srh4) (Entered: 09/12/2024) | |
09/12/2024 | 45 (1 pg) |
Order/Courtroom Minutes. Reset dismissal. Before Judge Norman, Jeffrey P. Related to document 39. Reset to 10/10/2024 at 09:30AM. (srh4) (Entered: 09/12/2024) | |
09/14/2024 | 46 (3 pgs) |
BNC Certificate of Mailing. (Related document(s):44 Courtroom Minutes/Order – R1 MI DJ ER JN CL) No. of Notices: 1. Notice Date 09/14/2024. (Admin.) (Entered: 09/14/2024) | |
09/14/2024 | 47 (3 pgs) |
BNC Certificate of Mailing. (Related document(s):45 Courtroom Minutes/Order – R6 MI DJ ER JN CL) No. of Notices: 1. Notice Date 09/14/2024. (Admin.) (Entered: 09/14/2024) |
PACER Service Center | |||
---|---|---|---|
Transaction Receipt | |||
09/17/2024 12:59:43 |
DUPFILER |
Southern District of Texas (Houston)
Bankruptcy Petition #: 24-33060
Assigned to: Bankruptcy Judge Jeffrey P Norman Chapter 13 Voluntary Asset
|
|
Debtor Jennifer Louise Robinson 3111 Longhorn Circle Manvel, TX 77578 BRAZORIA-TX SSN / ITIN: xxx-xx-5924 |
represented by | Eric Southward Busby & Associates 715 E Whitney St Houston, TX 77022 713-974-8099 Fax : 713-974-1181 Email: esouthward@busby-lee.com |
Trustee Tiffany D Castro Office of Chapter 13 Trustee 9821 Katy Freeway Ste 590 Houston, TX 77024 713-722-1200 |
||
U.S. Trustee US Trustee Office of the US Trustee 515 Rusk Ave Ste 3516 Houston, TX 77002 713-718-4650 |
Filing Date | # | Docket Text | |
---|---|---|---|
07/17/2024 | 26 (4 pgs) |
Notice to Individual Consumer Debtor Under 342(b) of the Bankruptcy Code. Filed by Jennifer Louise Robinson (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 07/17/2024) | |
07/18/2024 | 27 (2 pgs) |
Creditor Request for Notices (Filed By Deutsche Bank National Trust Company ). (Santini, Anthony) (Entered: 07/18/2024) | |
07/18/2024 | 28 (3 pgs) |
Notice of Appearance and Request for Notice Filed by Michael W Zientz Filed by on behalf of SELECT PORTFOLIO SERVICING, INC., as servicer for DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPANY, AS TRUSTEE, IN TRUST FOR REGISTERED HOLDERS OF LONG BEACH MORTGAGE LOAN TRUST 2006-7, ASSET-BACKED CERTIFICAT (Zientz, Michael) (Entered: 07/18/2024) | |
07/19/2024 | 29 (3 pgs) |
BNC Certificate of Mailing. (Related document(s):23 Order for EFT or ACH Payments) No. of Notices: 1. Notice Date 07/19/2024. (Admin.) (Entered: 07/19/2024) | |
07/24/2024 | 30 (2 pgs) |
Notice of Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Case, Meeting of Creditors & Notice of Appointment of Trustee.. 341(a) meeting to be held on 8/14/2024 at 01:30 PM, via Zoom – Castro: Meeting ID 223 248 9512, Passcode 1291903731, Phone 1 346 205 0870. Financial Management Course due:9/30/2024. Last day to object to dischargeability under section 523 is 10/15/2024. Proofs of Claims due by 9/9/2024. Government Proof of Claim due by 12/30/2024. Confirmation Hearing to be held on 9/16/2024 at 09:30 AM at Houston, Courtroom 403 (JPN). Clerk to send Notice on Financial Management Requirement 9/30/2024. (Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 07/24/2024) | |
07/26/2024 | 31 (5 pgs) |
BNC Certificate of Mailing – Meeting of Creditors. (Related document(s):30 Chapter 13 Meeting of Creditors (batch)) No. of Notices: 5. Notice Date 07/26/2024. (Admin.) (Entered: 07/26/2024) | |
07/30/2024 | 32 (22 pgs) |
Chapter 13 Trustee’s Notice of Confirmation Hearing and Plan Summary. (Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 07/30/2024) | |
08/01/2024 | 33 (3 pgs) |
Objection to Confirmation of Plan Filed by Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as Trustee, in trust for registered Holders of Long Beach Mortgage Loan Trust 2006-3, Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-3,. (Related document(s):19 Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary) (Dunn, George) (Entered: 08/01/2024) | |
08/01/2024 | 34 (25 pgs) |
BNC Certificate of Mailing. (Related document(s):32 Chapter 13 Trustee’s Notice of Confirmation Hearing and Plan Summary) No. of Notices: 3. Notice Date 08/01/2024. (Admin.) (Entered: 08/01/2024) | |
08/13/2024 | 35 (21 pgs) |
***Withdrawn at ECF 37***Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary Filed by Jennifer Louise Robinson. (Southward, Eric) Modified on 8/15/2024 (TraceyConrad). (Entered: 08/13/2024) | |
08/13/2024 | 36 (1 pg) |
Declaration Under Penalty of Perjury for Non-individual Debtors (Filed By Jennifer Louise Robinson ). (fmc2) (Entered: 08/13/2024) | |
08/14/2024 | 37 (2 pgs) |
Withdraw Document (Filed By Jennifer Louise Robinson ).(Related document(s):35 Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary) (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 08/14/2024) | |
08/15/2024 | 38 | Meeting of Creditors Held – Trustee Does Not Recommend Confirmation of the plan filed on 7/15/2024, document number 19. Debtor appeared. Meeting concluded . (Related document(s):30 Chapter 13 Meeting of Creditors (batch)) (Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 08/15/2024) | |
08/16/2024 | 39 (3 pgs) |
Chapter 13 Trustee’s Motion to Dismiss Case . Hearing scheduled for 9/16/2024 at 9:30 AM. (Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 08/16/2024) | |
08/21/2024 | 40 (3 pgs) |
Notice of Debtor’s Intention to Strip Lien. (Related document(s):19 Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary) Filed by Jennifer Louise Robinson (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 08/21/2024) | |
09/04/2024 | 41 (3 pgs) |
Notice of Appearance and Request for Notice Filed by Angela K Randermann Filed by on behalf of Brazoria County, et al (Randermann, Angela) (Entered: 09/04/2024) |
PACER Service Center | |||
---|---|---|---|
Transaction Receipt | |||
09/07/2024 07:56:41 |
Notice of Appearance and Request for Notice Filed by Angela K Randermann Filed by on behalf of Brazoria County, et al (Randermann, Angela) (Entered: 09/04/2024)
A “Notice of Debtor’s Intention to Strip Lien” is a formal document used in bankruptcy proceedings. It informs relevant parties, such as creditors and the court, that the debtor intends to remove or “strip” a lien from a piece of property.
In bankruptcy, a lien is a legal claim or right against property used as collateral to secure a debt. When someone files for bankruptcy, they might be able to eliminate certain liens if the value of the property is less than the amount owed on the lien, or if the lien is considered unsecured.
This notice is typically part of a bankruptcy plan and is used to alert interested parties about the debtor’s plans to address the lien, often as part of a broader strategy to reorganize or discharge debts.
Chapter 13 Trustee’s Motion to Dismiss Case .
Hearing scheduled for 9/16/2024 at 9:30 AM.
(Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 08/16/2024)
DUPFILER |
Southern District of Texas (Houston)
Bankruptcy Petition #: 24-33060
Assigned to: Bankruptcy Judge Jeffrey P Norman Chapter 13 Voluntary Asset
|
|
Debtor Jennifer Louise Robinson 3111 Longhorn Circle Manvel, TX 77578 BRAZORIA-TX SSN / ITIN: xxx-xx-5924 |
represented by | Eric Southward Busby & Associates 715 E Whitney St Houston, TX 77022 713-974-8099 Fax : 713-974-1181 Email: esouthward@busby-lee.com |
Trustee Tiffany D Castro Office of Chapter 13 Trustee 9821 Katy Freeway Ste 590 Houston, TX 77024 713-722-1200 |
||
U.S. Trustee US Trustee Office of the US Trustee 515 Rusk Ave Ste 3516 Houston, TX 77002 713-718-4650 |
Filing Date | # | Docket Text | |
---|---|---|---|
07/30/2024 | 32 (22 pgs) |
Chapter 13 Trustee’s Notice of Confirmation Hearing and Plan Summary. (Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 07/30/2024) | |
08/01/2024 | 33 (3 pgs) |
Objection to Confirmation of Plan Filed by Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as Trustee, in trust for registered Holders of Long Beach Mortgage Loan Trust 2006-3, Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-3,. (Related document(s):19 Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary) (Dunn, George) (Entered: 08/01/2024) | |
08/01/2024 | 34 (25 pgs) |
BNC Certificate of Mailing. (Related document(s):32 Chapter 13 Trustee’s Notice of Confirmation Hearing and Plan Summary) No. of Notices: 3. Notice Date 08/01/2024. (Admin.) (Entered: 08/01/2024) | |
08/13/2024 | 35 (21 pgs) |
***Withdrawn at ECF 37***Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary Filed by Jennifer Louise Robinson. (Southward, Eric) Modified on 8/15/2024 (TraceyConrad). (Entered: 08/13/2024) | |
08/13/2024 | 36 (1 pg) |
Declaration Under Penalty of Perjury for Non-individual Debtors (Filed By Jennifer Louise Robinson ). (fmc2) (Entered: 08/13/2024) | |
08/14/2024 | 37 (2 pgs) |
Withdraw Document (Filed By Jennifer Louise Robinson ).(Related document(s):35 Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary) (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 08/14/2024) | |
08/15/2024 | 38 | Meeting of Creditors Held – Trustee Does Not Recommend Confirmation of the plan filed on 7/15/2024, document number 19. Debtor appeared. Meeting concluded . (Related document(s):30 Chapter 13 Meeting of Creditors (batch)) (Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 08/15/2024) | |
08/16/2024 | 39 (3 pgs) |
Chapter 13 Trustee’s Motion to Dismiss Case . Hearing scheduled for 9/16/2024 at 9:30 AM. (Castro, Tiffany) (Entered: 08/16/2024) | |
08/21/2024 | 40 (3 pgs) |
Notice of Debtor’s Intention to Strip Lien. (Related document(s):19 Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary) Filed by Jennifer Louise Robinson (Southward, Eric) (Entered: 08/21/2024) |
PACER Service Center | |||
---|---|---|---|
Transaction Receipt | |||
08/22/2024 15:02:38 |
Objection to Confirmation of Plan Filed by Deutsche Bank by RASC's lawyer George Dunn (Aug. 1, 2024)
Objection to Confirmation of Plan Filed by Deutsche Bank National Trust Company, as Trustee, in trust for registered Holders of Long Beach Mortgage Loan Trust 2006-3, Asset-Backed Certificates, Series 2006-3,. (Related document(s):19 Chapter 13 Plan, Chapter 13 Plan Summary) (Dunn, George) (Entered: 08/01/2024)
Notice of Appearance and Request for Notice Filed by Michael W Zientz Filed by on behalf of SELECT PORTFOLIO SERVICING, INC., as servicer for DEUTSCHE BANK NATIONAL TRUST COMPANY, AS TRUSTEE, IN TRUST FOR REGISTERED HOLDERS OF LONG BEACH MORTGAGE LOAN TRUST 2006-7, ASSET-BACKED CERTIFICAT (Zientz, Michael) (Entered: 07/18/2024)
Mr. Southward is a member of the State Bar of Indiana and is admitted to practice in the Southern District of Texas, Northern District of Illinois, and the Northern and Southern Districts of Indiana. He is a member of the Houston Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys and the National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys. Mr. Southward has Eighteen years of federal bankruptcy and consumer law experience. Prior to joining Busby & Associates, he was a Senior Managing Attorney with Legal Helpers, P.C., a national bankruptcy firm headquartered in Chicago, Illinois. While at Legal Helpers, Eric oversaw its regional offices and previously managed its Indianapolis, Indiana office.
Prior to the practice of law, Mr. Southward was a marketing manager with an advertising and marketing firm and a pharmaceutical research company, both based in Indianapolis, Indiana. Prior to that, he was a national account manager with magazine publishing services company based in Des Moines, Iowa.
Although raised and schooled in Iowa, Eric is a native Texan, born in Corpus Christi. He has re-joined his family, who all reside in the greater Houston area now. Mr. Southward received his undergraduate degree in 1992 from Buena Vista University in Storm Lake, Iowa, and his law degree in 1999 from Indiana University.
LIT Previously wrote an article about Jennifer Robinson and Vilt’s case.
Robinson v. Deutsche Bank National Trust Company
(3:23-cv-00170)
District Court, S.D. Texas, Judge Jeff Brown
JUN 8, 2023 – FEB 1, 2024 | REPUBLISHED BY LIT: AUG 22, 2024
Dismissed with prejudice after motion for summary judgment fully briefed. Robinson’s foreclosure, set for July 2, 2024 would be cancelled after she filed for bankruptcy protection in SDTX.