As with the Boy Scouts, where practically every judge sends their kids, the Catholic Church is another protected legal community.
The Due Process Clause requires recusal whenever there is an unconstitutional “probability” or “potential” for bias. Rippo v. Baker.
Judge King sat on another recent appeal panel re internet searches involving Judge Lynn Hughes who looked up a litigant's company erroneously
"...an appellate court will mandate reassignment when the facts “might reasonably cause an objective observer to question the original judge’s impartiality.”"