Federal Judges

When You Lose at the Lower Court. You Hire Former Ninth Circuit Chief Judge and You Win Reversal on Appeal.

Former Chief Ninth Circuit Judge Alex Kozinski, the Judicial Council of the Ninth Circuit and others should not be allowed to duck a retaliation suit filed by an attorney who contends he was targeted after drawing eyes to pornography the judge purportedly posted online

 American Justice in Federal Courts.

Originally Published; Dec. 6, 2019 | LIT Republished; Feb 23, 2021

It’s based on who you are, who you know, and how deep your wallet is to fix the case. And in this case, it was reversed in a short 2-page opinion in favor of Kozinski’s client and is completely opposite to how his sexual misconduct case is proceeding, which is not going well for the plaintiff and being slowed down with a litany of denied motions by the Chief Judge in the lower court, Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers.

He’s Back. After Resigning, Federal Judge Accused of Sexual Harassment Returns As A Practitioner

Originally Published; Dec. 6, 2019 | LIT Republished; Feb 23, 2021

Alex Kozinski was a powerful judge at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit for decades until he resigned in 2017 after at least 15 female law clerks and staffers accused him of sexual harassment.

He left with a full pension and his law license.

It turns out that Kozinski did not go far. He is now practicing law before the 9th Circuit, where Law.com reports he is scheduled to make oral arguments on Monday as an advocate in a copyright case.


Kozinski represents David Zindel, who unsuccessfully sued Fox Searchlight Pictures, Inc., for allegedly misappropriating the substance of a play written by Zindel’s late Pulitzer Prize-winning father, Paul, in 1969. The defendants include Guillermo del Toro, who wrote, directed and produced the film, “The Shape of Water,” which won an Academy Award for Best Picture in 2018.

Why would Zindel want Kozinski to represent him before the 9th court?

Kozinski spent 32 years as a federal court judge in California, including a stint a chief judge of the 9th Circuit. He knows the court and he knows the judges. These are normally advantages to any litigant.

So what if at least 15 women, including many who are now prominent female lawyers and law professors, accused him of sexual harassing them when they were vulnerable law clerks?

Law License

Court officials claimed they had no jurisdiction to punish Kosinski after he resigned but what about his law license?

It’s Time To Stop Even Casually Misusing Disability Words
State bar associations, including California’s, require applicants to be of “good moral character” to practice law. The California bar routinely suspends lawyers who demonstrate bad behavior.

Among other things, The Washington Post reported that Kozinski touched a recent law student’s breast, supposedly to fully see her name tag, at 2016 reception. Another lawyer said he approached her when she was alone in a room at a legal community event around 2008 and gave her a bear hug and kissed her on the lips. A former U.S. Court of Federal Claims judge said Kozinski squeezed her breasts as the two drove back from an event in the mid-1980s, after she said she did not want to stop at a motel and have sex. He allegedly showed a clerk porn on his computer and asked if it turned her on.

At least two of Kozinski’s law clerks resigned, which likely was a serious blow to promising careers.


The kid gloves treatment of Kozinski by the 9th Circuit in 2018 highlighted the vexing problem of sexual harassment in the federal judiciary, where approximately three-quarters of all judges are male and they have lifetime tenure under Article III of the U.S. Constitution.

After an outcry over Kozinski’s departure, U.S. Supreme Court Chief Judge John G. Roberts, Jr., announced the formation of a working group to come up with a plan for dealing with sexual harassment. The group called for clearer standards, streamlined procedures for making complaints and more training.

Congress passed a law in 1980, the Judicial Conduct and Disability Act, that makes federal judges responsible for disciplining one another. This has been less than a success.

The Los Angeles Times reported in 2008 that Kozinski contributed to a website featuring sexually explicit photos and videos, including a photograph of naked women on all fours painted to look like cows and a video of a half-dressed man cavorting with a sexually aroused farm animal.

A panel of federal judges from another federal circuit admonished Kozinski, saying he’d been careless, but noting the web site folder had been made public because of an improper security configuration.

Predatory Lending: Experts Confirm Lender Loan Application and Mortgage Fraud Paid $2.6M in Fees

The Greatest Theft of Citizens Homes in American History: This case proves Lender Underwriting Fraud. Citizens Homes Are Still Being Stolen.

Ninth Circuit Affirms on Appeal PHH Mortgage Corp, NewRez, and HSBC Bank Violated Automatic Stay

PHH Mortgage Corporation, NewRez, LLC, and HSBC Bank USA, N.A. violated the stay; and declined to annul the stay.

Indymac Bank’s Victor Woodworth: This is What Jail Looks Like for the Sr VP of Predatory Lending

You will note in the FDIC litigation involving Indymac Bank, Victor Woodworth is listed as Senior Vice President.

When You Lose at the Lower Court. You Hire Former Ninth Circuit Chief Judge and You Win Reversal on Appeal.
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

To Top